Compared to the world-class maternity wards and birthing facilities available to mamas here in Singapore, the women of Kabul, Afghanistan had only one safe place to give birth in – the Dasht-e-Barchi Hospital.
Zahra Koochizad has been working as a midwife with Médecins Sans Frontieres (MSF, aka Doctors Without Borders) since 2018 in Kabul, Afghanistan. She comes from a family of midwives and that, coupled with her strong desire to serve her own people, inspired her to become a midwife too. On May 12th 2020, the Dasht-e-Barchi Hospital was attacked, killing 24 people, including 15 mothers. Zahra was on duty that day as the midwife supervisor at the maternity ward.
When I first saw news of this attack in May, I was quick to keep scrolling and paid no mind to the story – there’s already so much happening in the world (Covid-19! The Black Lives Matter movement! The ongoing fight against misogyny!). Did we really need to hear about more tragedy? But when my fellow mama friend, MSF Communications Officer in Singapore Sarah Bagharib, sent this op-ed to me, I couldn’t look away and my heart shattered.
Afghanistan has been plagued by war for over 40 years due to the conflict between its government and the Taliban, who holds power over much of the country. Under their militant regime, the country has faced brutality, massacres and famine. Could the women and infants who were safe in the Dasht-e-Barchi Hospital have really posed a threat to the militant group, for them to conduct such a senseless act?
Below, Zahra shares her thoughts about the day of the attack.
As midwives in Afghanistan, we bring new life into this country under conditions more difficult than in most. Approximately 130 million babies are born worldwide every year. This also means there are millions of women needing assistance to go through their pregnancy and labour. Giving birth, in my opinion, is one of the most glorious and most critical moments in a woman’s life.
My passion to see new life coming into the world and my strong desire to serve my own people made me choose to become a midwife. It also comes from my family’s involvement in this vocation. Some of my aunts and cousins also work as midwives in different hospitals in Kabul. They also chose this profession because of their desire to serve, and because they learned that, in Afghanistan, most women who die in childbirth, died from preventable complications.
Despite some improvements over the past years, Afghanistan has one of the highest maternal and newborn mortality rates in the world, and the need for specialised care is vital. In Switzerland, five mothers will die per 100,000 live births. In Afghanistan, this number jumps to 638 who will die; this does not include the 15 mothers and five unborn babies who were systematically shot dead in the maternity ward where I work a month ago.
One of the biggest challenges that every midwife and pregnant woman in Afghanistan faces is insecurity. I’ve painfully experienced this first-hand.
I’m the midwife supervisor in the MSF-run maternity wing of Dasht-e-Barchi hospital in Kabul. The attack there occurred on 12 May. I remember that day; we had very nice weather, the air was fresh, and I felt a sense of peace when entering the hospital. Once I arrived, I saw my colleagues working; they all looked motivated and eager to start a new day of providing services to pregnant women in need. On a daily basis, we are used to tragedy in our communities, but nothing could have prepared us for the horror to come.
In Afghanistan, a maternity ward is one of the few spaces where women are the leaders. The terrorists entered an area where no men are ever allowed to go. They stormed the maternity wing armed with guns, killing pregnant women, new mothers and newborns. Their leader must be very proud; celebrating a victory over an army of one-day old babies and women wearing only their hospital robes.
A hospital is supposed to be a protected space. It says this under international humanitarian law and yet the assault on my maternity wing is not an exceptional case – attacks on healthcare happen frequently here. But what is different about this attack than all the others?
Because, as midwives in Afghanistan, we are the silent leaders of our country. We are at the bedside of pregnant women giving birth to the country’s future and we need to be protected. To safeguard a maternity wing like mine is to safeguard our future, along with the midwives working there. Midwives like our beloved Maryam, who was killed in the most incomprehensible way as she assisted soon-to-be mothers giving birth.
On the day of the four-hour assault on Dasht-e-Barchi maternity wing, the terrorists not only attacked pregnant women and newborns, but also the decades of work involved to reduce maternal and newborn mortality in Afghanistan. Because of this attack, the western area of Kabul, with more than one million inhabitants, and women coming from far away provinces, no longer have access to any comprehensive obstetric and newborn care.
Their only option now is a 50-bed hospital close by, but with only seven beds devoted to maternity services, I do not know if the pregnant women who go there, or to other hospitals, are being cared for as they need. Will they receive the help they need? Will they have the means to pay for hospital services? Will they survive their labour if they are not admitted to any hospital?
I am scared to think about what will happen to those women who would have otherwise come to us.
Each month, the MSF-run maternity wing provided quality services to more than 1,200 mothers who delivered their babies there. I know that if the women in the Dasht-e-Barchi area need childbirth assistance, they would go to the 50-bed hospital, but if they have any complications, they will not be admitted there. There is no operating theatre for emergency cases, for example. And with the COVID-19 pandemic, the options for women who have complications or special needs are even fewer, and farther away, than before.
Most patients that come to Dasht-e-Barchi belong to the Hazara community and don’t have the means to pay for their treatment in other places. Some of the women arrive at the hospital in terrible conditions.
I can recall one patient in particular. She came to us for the first time, but she could hardly walk and looked very pale. She came from an area that’s on the outskirts of Kabul. I examined her and realised she had severe anaemia; there was no antenatal care available where she lived. Due to the lack of means to buy food, she was not eating properly, and when I asked her when she had last eaten, her answer was ‘yesterday’. My heart broke upon hearing that, but I was so happy to see her recover and give birth to a healthy baby.
Her story is just one of the thousands that describes the reality of life for patients in the Dasht-e-Barchi area; some of whom would come to the hospital and not have money to get back home.
All of our patients and the wider community were very happy to count on our maternity wing that provided services for free, especially since government hospitals charge some amount of money. I am saddened to see how poverty, lack of a good health system, lack of resources, insecurity and the COVID-19 pandemic are limiting possibilities for people to receive proper healthcare. Healthcare centres in Kabul are already operating at reduced capacity because some of their staff are infected with COVID-19.
I am hurt, my life has changed, but I am still committed to continue my work. I know my people need us and expect me to get back on my feet again with the support of MSF. I cannot forget all those patients who need a helping hand and a good level of care. I also want to honour all of those patients who have become our friends and have been praying for me. I do not want to disappoint them, especially now, when many are also suffering from COVID-19 pandemic.
I see our people suffering from greater obstacles, in a situation which is already critical – and the need for healthcare services has never been greater.
– Zahra Koochizad
MSF announced on 15 June its decision to end activities and withdraw from Dasht-e-Barchi in Kabul following the brutal attack. An MSF midwife working for the organisation, two children aged 7 and 8 and six other people present at the time of the attack were also killed. The decision comes with the understanding that while no information has emerged about the perpetrators or motive of the assault, mothers, babies and health staff were its deliberate target, and similar attacks may repeat in the future.
Doctors Without Borders/ Médecins Sans
If you live in Singapore and wish to donate to MSF, you may do so via ssl.msf.hk. If you wish to find out more ways to collaborate with MSF, please write to Karunya Prabaharan, at [email protected]